Archive for November 22, 2026

Old Man Yells at The Cloud: GTA6 vs Ocarina of Time (Re-re-make)

Posted in Grumblings with tags , , , , on November 22, 2026 by chemiclord

Well, first things first, I’m glad I am finally able to sit back down and enjoy an occasional weekend after months of campaigning, both for myself and others. Being a small part of the massive blue catastrophe for conservatives in America was rewarding, and I’m looking forward to actually serving my community in a positive way for the next two years (at least).

But I digress, on to the show you came to see!

Ah, it’s that most wonderful time of the year; family, friends, presents, good will towards all, and maniacal fighting by various video game fans as they pretend to leverage their favorite game in the hopes that it will be breathlessly slobbered over by that stale mayo stained rag in a tuxedo named Geoff Keighley.

On an aside, has anyone in the industry ever had a bigger footprint in gaming while providing less than Geoff Keighley?

(Yes, Nix. I see you. Yes, your Maximillian Dood flag is quite visible. Yes, I see it has several knife wounds and is half burnt. We’ll talk later.)

At any rate, having gaming fans at each others throats this time of year is nothing particularly new, but this year, the rancor is definitely at a level we haven’t seen in a good long time, if ever. There’s some genuine animosity here that extends beyond simply Game of the Year awards. We are seeing a generational battle between two heavily invested groups that both sit at the most highly regarded titles of all time.

This is the Jordan vs Lebron of video games here folks. It’s Mike Tyson vs Muhammad Ali. For reasons that have some pretty decent parallels, as it isn’t merely a clash of raw numbers; it’s a clash of styles, design, and intent.

(Disclosure: yes, I am going to abbreviate Grand Theft Auto 6 frequently, but not Ocarina of Time. It’s not out of an specific deference to Ocarina of Time. I just get a sickening tingle in my spine typing OoT.)

In this corner: We have Grand Theft Auto 6! The latest entry in a long line of critically acclaimed titles, just barely squeaking in at the weight limit at the very last minute in order to eligible at all! And in the other corner: we have The Ocarina of Time, which is technically the remake of a game that was already remade to begin with! Personally, I wouldn’t have considered it eligible for GotY awards to begin with, but Geoff needed something to at least pretend to stir up drama and uncertainty for the Game Awards, and pretty much every publisher not named Nintendo was too chickenshit to try and release something in GTA6’s orbit!

Grand Theft Auto 6 is, in many ways, a culmination of the current era of gaming. Huge cinematic experiences with massive budgets, gigantic sprawling open worlds with nigh boundless freedom, the illusion of choice around every corner, an attempt to simulate a real, breathing world all within a single game. This is arguably the defining game for a generation of gamers that has desperately wanted games and gaming to be considered a real, quality, respected art form among the general population.

Ocarina of Time, on the other hand, is the product of an era with… well I won’t say smaller ambitions, but more different ambitions. It hails from a time where game developers were just starting to seriously render 3D spaces on a 2D surface. This is a game of exploration in a different sense; rather than exploring a carefully crafted world, exploring the tools of the craft themselves, introducing game mechanics and philosophy that would influence games for the next three decades.

GTA6 is a refinement of what is possible in modern gaming; Ocarina of Time was an exploration of what possible to begin with.

On top of that, both games represent a pinnacle of the general design philosophy of their respective generations. GTA6 represents so much of what has become the predominant style of this period. A focus on graphical fidelity and massive sprawling open environments to explore, even at the cost of performance. GTA6 frequently struggles to reach 30fps game performance in exchange for gorgeous settings, locations, and characters.

Meanwhile, Ocarina of Time comes from a era of carefully curated and a by comparison linear experience that maximizes performance, utilizing art style for the aesthetics rather than the game engine, sacrificing crisp details and textures for smooth gameplay. As a result, you have an image that definitely looks rough if you look closely enough, but in the heat of the action gets lost in the smooth and stable frame rate.

So what you have is two groups of people who are very invested in their chosen philosophy, and if there is any way to guarantee animosity between two sets of people, bring philosophy into it. Which one is “better?” I don’t know. That’s really just going to be a matter of personal taste.

But it sure as hell isn’t worth the drama going on right now.